Spacer

Chocolate or Vanilla?

Chocolate or Vanilla

Which would you choose?

Would it matter if I wasn’t talking about cupcakes that you eat?

What if it was something that you wear?

Johnny Cupcakes

Hmmm? I wonder what’s in there.

Well, I ordered something a few weeks ago from Johnny Cupcakes. They sell tons of cool shirts with their cupcake logo in all kinds of designs.

And this one is really cute. Like super cute. At least I think so.

As soon as I saw it, I had to place an order online.

Frosting Cans

And then these arrived a few days later. Magic.

They’re frosting label paint cans. But instead of paint or even frosting, they are filled with a fluffy t-shirt in chocolate or vanilla.

I’m a sucker for cute packaging and these are over the top.

Frosting-shirts

The shirts are designed to look like the packaging label and would be adorable on.

That’s if you can bring yourself to open the can.

Me? I would have to sit mine on a shelf unopened with the shirt cuddled inside so I could look at it all the time. And especially after I found out these frosting can t-shirts were printed as a limited edition. When I bought them, I didn’t realize they only printed 200 of each. And, yes – they are sold out. All sizes. All colors. Gone. They had strawberry too, but those were scooped up first.

The good news is I have two of them. I was going to keep one. But since I’m only going to put it on a shelf and look at it. And since I don’t even have a bookshelf to put it on – I thought I would give them both away.

So which would you choose?

Chocolate Frosting Can

Chocolate?

Vanilla Frosting Can

Or vanilla?

Frosting Cans

Enter for a chance to win
A Sold Out Limited Edition Johnny Cupcakes Frosting Label T-shirt

(in a super cute can – Size XL)

  • To enter, just let me know which flavor you’d like to have in the comments section here on the website. Easy.
  • Deadline to enter is Wednesday, June 6th at 6 pm ET. SORRY, Time’s Up! Winners announced below.
  • Two winners will be chosen at random and announced on this post at the end of the week.
  • The first person chosen at random will win the shirt and can in the flavor of their choice and the second winner drawn will win the remaining flavor. And if we’re lucky they’ll be both person’s flavorite!

Good Luck!

Giveaway sponsored by me.

We have winners. And a lot of chocolate lovers. No surprise. I wish I had time to create a chart to show the comparison from all of the entries… that would be interesting. But luckily this little giveaway worked out great and for both winners.

The first winner is Charlton (comment #1927). Congrats! You’re getting the chocolate shirt.

And the second winner is Tami (comment # 301) Yay for you too! You’re getting the vanilla shirt.

cupcakeshirt-winners

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4,215 comments on “Chocolate or Vanilla?”

  1. I love the chocolate can/shirt and I LOVE Johnny Cupcakes! Would be so thrilled to have one!

  2. I would take either, love chocolate. Honestly I would ust like those cupcakes that in the picture, they look delicious!

  3. Either!!!! I’m in love with both!!!!
    Can’t help it! And, thank you for always sharing with us!

  4. I would always pick chocolate.

  5. Chocolate, definitely chocolate!

  6. Chocolate!

  7. CHOCOLATE!!!! I love everything chocolate. These cans are the vintage look I love.

  8. Chocolate of course!

  9. hmmm….normally I would say chocolate, but I really like the vanilla shirt and the hubs prefers vanilla soo….VANILLA it is!

  10. Yum! Chocolate for sure.

  11. Ha! Super cute….and I’m a BIG fan of either favor!

  12. oooh! how cute! I would have to go for chocolate I think, my desk drawer is full of chocolate treats after all

  13. Chocolate, please!

  14. Both are cute, but chocolate would look better on me. But if I were eating a cupcake, I would go vanilla all the way. LOL!

  15. Chocolate!

  16. Chocolate! Yum! But I like Vanilla too! Either one! So cute!! Thanks for the fun contests.

  17. Definately chocolate!!!

  18. vanilla all the way!

  19. Ultimate favorite Chocolate!

  20. Vanilla! these are so adorable!

  21. Chocolate! Those shirts are too adorable.

  22. Chocolate! I need to add to my drawer of quirky, awesome shirts!

  23. Chocolate!!!

  24. Vanilla!!!

  25. Chocolate! Always chocolate!

    … since it’s an extra-large, I’ll even be able to share it with my DH. That’s actually kind of awesome.

  26. I am a chocolate girl all the way!

  27. Chocolate please!

  28. Chocolate!

  29. Vanilla please

  30. Chocolate

  31. I would choose CHOCOLATE :)
    and I would ware the T-shirt and display the can in my kitchen

  32. Chocolate of course!!

  33. Chocolate :)

  34. Vanilla, but I see why you would buy both. I bet strawberry was super cute too. The whole set would be cute on the counter.

  35. I am going with vanilla!! all the way!!

  36. Super cute but vanilla all the way!

  37. Chocolate! Both are cute but me and white shirts don’t mix well.

  38. I can never turn down chocolate!

  39. Chocolate. Always. :)

  40. Downright chocolate, vanilla’s a bit too sweet for me :)

  41. Chocolate! :)

  42. Chocolate would be my choice :)

  43. Oh I’m all about the chocolate!

  44. I would definitely pick chocolate! You can never go wrong with chocolate!

  45. chocolate for sure!

  46. Chocolate!!!!

  47. I’d go for chocolate. very tasty!

  48. Vanilla because my hubby likes vanilla and today is our 36th wedding anniversary. So Vanilla even though I like chocolate. LOL

  49. Vanilla please but either would be amazing!

  50. Vanilla! :)

  51. Chocolate!

  52. mmmm definitely chocolate!!!

  53. While chocolate is delicious, I’d have to go for vanilla!
    3 cheers for vanilla!

  54. My favorite is chocolate, but i do not discriminate when it comes to sweets!

  55. Vanilla please!

  56. woot woot!! free icing!! Chocolate <3

  57. Super cute! Vanillllllllaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!

  58. Vanilla! yum yum! But the chocolate shirt is cute too!

  59. Chocolate all the way!

  60. Definitely Chocolate!

  61. CCCHHHHOOOOOCCCCOOOOLLLLAAAATTTTEEEEE!!!!

  62. Vanilla

  63. Those shirts are too cute! I would love anything CHOCOLATE!

  64. You simply cannot go wrong with Chocolate!

  65. I love them both….but if I have to choose “vanilla”!

  66. Chocolate please!!

  67. Vanilla! I’m a sucker for the classic vanilla.

  68. Chocolate!!!

  69. CHOCOLATE! Can I have one of the cupcakes in the pic too? Pretty please.

  70. Chocolate!!

  71. Vanilla :)

  72. Chocolate! Whether eating it, wearing it or just staring at it on the shelf, the preference for sure is chocolate, chocolate, chocolate!!

  73. Chocolate!

  74. Chocolate wins in my book!

  75. I’m a chocolate girl, but for this shirt I’d go with vanilla! :)

  76. Chocolate!!!

  77. Chocolate for sure!

  78. mmmm so hard to choose! Im gonna have to go with chocolate, although the vanilla is cute too :)

  79. Vanilla! those are sooooo cute. :)

  80. I would choose chocolate but I’d be thrilled to win either one.

  81. The chocolate shirt would be best for me….love the rich color!

  82. Vanilla!

  83. If I were eating them, I’d say definitely chocolate… but the shirts are both so adorable! Maybe vanilla. =)

  84. I would like vanilla because the vanilla can is soooo cute with the torquise writing on it.

  85. Vanilla for the shirt and chocolate for the cupcake. Now I need to go to the store and get some cupcakes.

  86. Hard to decide…Vanilla it is! Thanks for sharing Bakerella.

  87. Chocolate! Definitely! Who could refuse that wonderful ‘fudgey’ looking goodness. But, it would be *really* had to say no to that fluffy, vanilla white confection either.

  88. I am a Vanilla girl thru and thru!

  89. That’s like asking a pregnant lady…boy or girl. But I guess I will be decisive and say “CHOCOLATE”!

  90. Chocolate is my addiction : ) But I would ear the vanilla shirt way more, so vanilla it is!

  91. Chocolate!

  92. I would like the chocolate shirt because I am just not a vanilla kind of girl!

  93. Chocolate……mmmmmmm

  94. Chocolate, please!

  95. I gotta go with Chocolate…cause I’m a Fudge!

  96. CHOCOLATE!!!!!!

  97. Vanilla, I’m a natural kind of girl!!

  98. I love them both…they are so cute! I would probably choose the vanilla, but I really do love both :)

  99. Wow I love them both but since I live in an RV with two cats a dog and a passion for baking white is just not my friend even though I love it. The chocolate is really pretty. BTW your blog is amazing I made some lemon curd mini tarts last night and have been trying to photograph them like you do your sweets but so far it’s been a dud :/

    I have to go with chocolate !

  100. Vanilla ;)

  101. Gotta go with chocolate!
    Love the idea :-)

  102. Chocolate!

  103. Chocolate! In both clothing and food!

  104. Vanilla frosting, vanilla cookies, vanilla ice cream!

  105. Easy choice: Chocolate. And I am dying to sink my teeth into one of those beautiful chocolate cupcakes!

  106. Chocolate :)

  107. I would love to eat (oops) wear the Vanilla shirt.

  108. So cute! I love chocolate!

  109. It’s so cruel that you make us pick a favorite flavor ;-) Okay after a good long hard thinking, i have to go for chocolate.

  110. I would love the chocolate. It would be my baking uniform and the vanilla would always get stained with chocolate, so I would look cleaner in the chocolate.

  111. Chocolate all the way! yum!

  112. Both are adorable! I am with you- too cute to open! Would opening the can ruin it? Or could you open it AND still have the cute-as-can-be paint can intact? I think chocolate would be my fav because I like browns. ; )

  113. chocolate of course!

  114. Chocolate, Chocolate, Chocolate!!! Would love vanilla too, and now I need to go bake….

  115. CHOCOLATE, most definitely; is there any other flavour? :)

  116. I’m kookoo for CHOCOLATE!

  117. Chocolate!!!

  118. Chocolate!!

  119. No doubt! CHOCOLATE all the way!!

  120. Vanilla in everything for me, from cupcakes to ice cream. Those t-shirts are so cute though I’d do either flavour. What a great give away as always. Thanks!

  121. I’m not picky when it comes to cupcakes or cake. They both look DELICIOUS, but I would probably choose chocolate!!

  122. Chocolate!!! Forever and always chocolate!!!!

  123. Chocolate!!! Mmmmmm…..

  124. That is adorable! Really sweet of you to do a giveaway of those cute shirts. I’m a chocolate type of girl:)lol.

    Peace, Love, & Cricut Hug’s!
    Monica L.

  125. Chocolate! Didn’t even have to think about it.

  126. Oh man, both are SO cute! Even though in taste I’m a ‘both’ girl (chocolate cake with vanilla icing), I’m going to pick CHOCOLATE for the shirt!

  127. I love chocolate, but then again, I love vanilla too!! But, I’ll go with vanilla!! :)

  128. Hard choice but I have to say chocolate, but I really like the one vanilla too!

  129. definitely chocolate all the way!

  130. Chocolate, like me… ;)

  131. Love your blog!
    Would love the chocolate t-shirt! And the XL size would fit my huge pregnant self! Thank you for the chance to win, you’re a doll!

  132. Chocolate!

  133. chocolate :)

  134. They are so adorable! I love both! But Vanilla is probably my favourite :) what a cute giveaway! Love your recipes x x

  135. I’ve always been a chocoholic, but let it be known that when it comes to these adorable shirts, I wouldn’t be picky!

  136. Vanilla! It’s not boring…it’s a classic :)

  137. I’m smiling because I would do the same thing with the packaging! I would probably take out the shirt – if it didn’t ruin the packaging! And if I had seen these, I would have bought both flavors because I would have been able to decide too! Some days are chocolate days and some are vanilla! I think today is a vanilla day! Thanks for the giveaway and as always your generosity!

  138. Definitely vanilla! Super cute :)

  139. Chocolate!
    Although if I’m really eating a cupcake, I like marble. With chocolate frosting.

  140. Definitely vanilla. I’m allergic to chocolate!

  141. oooo I must say Chocolate, but vanilla looks appetizing too….but still CHOCOLATE!

  142. definitely vanilla!

  143. Chocolate definitely!

  144. The both are yummy!! But I am Chocolate!!!!!!!

  145. Vanilla!! Who says it’s boring?

  146. Is Swirl an option? I love Chocolate! But the Vanilla can looks cool, too. Either one would b AWESOME!!

  147. Chocolate, Chocolate….always chocolate!

  148. Chocolate please :)

  149. Chocolate always!!!!!

  150. Vanilla is my pick!
    How sweet are you! :)
    Thanks for the giveaway and for sharing!
    You rock!
    PS…..my birthday is June 20th…:)

  151. Chocolate, of course :)!

  152. Chocolate – always chocolate! But is there is no chocolate, then Vanilla works just fine!

  153. CHOCOLATE! But I am going to slather some graham crackers with it and set them in the freezer to eat when my kids are asleep!!! Mom time!

  154. OH gosh! They’re adorable! Vanilla!

  155. Vanilla, please!

  156. Chocolate.

  157. Chocolate!

  158. Chocolate!!! Thanks for the opportunity!

  159. Chocolate!

  160. The chocolate one would be divine!

  161. I’ve never really won anything at a raffel nor at a give away. :)) I wuld really like a cupcake shirt.! :)) plz let me win!

  162. Chocolate!!! No doubt about it!

  163. Hmmm i’m kinda liking the chocolate :)

  164. The hands down winner for me is ……. CHOCOLATE!!!!

  165. Vanilla! Especially because I love the white and blue color combo on the t-shirt – great giveaway!

  166. Chocolate, Vanilla, Chocolate, Vanilla, I can’t decide:
    CHOCOLATE!

  167. Recently I have developed a love of the vanilla bean, but chocolate has always been a favorite of mine. :) If I had to choose, it’d be old faithful, chocolate.

  168. Chocolate always wins for me :)

  169. Vanilla –

  170. I love them both, but chocolate is always the winner for me.

  171. Vanilla!!

  172. Chocolate, but vanilla is super cute too!

  173. Vanilla!! thanks Bakerella

  174. Super Cute!!! I would pick Vanilla for sure!!

  175. Chocolate!!!!!! Although Vanilla is nice too…. ;)

  176. Chocolate!!!

  177. Vanilla!

  178. Chocolate!!! :)

  179. I would be happy either way but my first choice would be vanilla!!!

  180. It is so hard to choose…I guess it would have to be chocolate. Thanks for doing such an awesome giveaway!

  181. Chocolate…. Of course!!

  182. Chocolate! These are just so adorable!

  183. Chocolate!!!

  184. I think i would look better in Chocolate than vanilla. and please include one cupcake, they look yummy!

  185. I’ll go with Vanilla. I love Chocolate too but think the Vanilla shirt is just a tad cuter.

  186. Totally chocolate!!

  187. I would have to say Vanilla! How fun

  188. I’m a chocolate girl at heart but I’m kinda digging vanilla right now. So count me in for vanilla!

  189. Vanilla!

  190. I would choose Vanilla!! Yum!

  191. Chocolate!! So cute…

  192. I would love to win the chocolate one, but the vanilla is super cute too!

Leave a Comment »